DAYTON, Ohio (WDTN) — It was the defense’s turn to call its witness on the third day of the Abby Michaels trial as they focused on her mental state on the night of St. Patrick’s Day 2019. They also shared what might have caused her to go the wrong way on I-75.
Wednesday afternoon at the Montgomery County Courthouse, the prosecutor and defense did a deep dive in Michaels’ repeated trauma in her childhood and how it might have played a role in the crash.
The defense called Dr. Christina Waite, the director of psychiatry at Miami Valley Hospital, to the stand. She treated Michaels one week after the crash, and said that in her opinion Michaels likely suffered a psychogenetic seizure right before the crash.
According to Dr. Waite, repeated childhood trauma resulted in conditions that could cause seizures or misassociation while under stress, such as dealing with Michaels’ divorce.
Dr. Waite also said Michaels suffered from Borderline Personality Disorder, which can often result in psychotic breaks and loss of control.
“The thinking part of the brain basically gets overwhelmed and checks out,” Dr. Waite said.
Dr. Waite said Michaels was unaware and displayed poor insight for many weeks after the crash. When she began to become more aware, Michaels and her family told Waite that causing harm like the collision was not in her nature.
The prosecution presented evidence that Michaels had not had a documented seizure from 2016 up to March 2019. Dr. Waite pointed out that this does not mean she did not have one, only that she did not seek medical care.
Michaels has pleaded not guilty to six counts of murder and three counts of aggravated vehicular homicide in a St. Patrick’s Day 2019 head-on collision that killed a mother and father and their 10-year-old daughter.
We’re here for Day 3 of the Abby Michaels trial at the Montgomery County Courthouse.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
Today, the defense was scheduled to begin at 1:30 p.m., however as of 2:45 p.m. the courtroom doors remain closed. (Thread)
The third day of the trial has now begun. pic.twitter.com/25wlpxFpI7
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
The defense has called Dr. Christina Waite to the stand as an expert in the field of psychiatry. Dr. Waite works as the director of psychiatry at Miami Valley Hospital. She has testified as an expert in multiple cases before this one.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
Waite also treated Abby Michaels one week after the crash occurred.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
According to Dr. Waite, repeated childhood trauma resulted in conditions that could cause seizures and disassociation while under stress, for example, while dealing with a divorce.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
Dr. Waite also said Michaels suffered from Borderline Personality Disorder, which can often result in psychotic breaks and loss of control.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
“The thinking part of the brain basically gets overwhelmed and checks out.”
Dr. Waite and the defense are walking through documents from Michaels’s time at Dayton Children’s Hospital when she was younger. These documents do indicate that Michaels suffered from what may have been both epileptic and psychogenic seizures in the past.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
Dr. Waite explained her shock at reading that the initial reports indicated the crash had been intentional.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
“Gosh, have they interviewed the patient, have they interviewed the family? Because as I understand it, she was in a coma.”
“I suppose that’s why I’m here today: because people need to know the brain is an organ and psychiatric problems are real.” – Dr. Christina Waite.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
Dr. Waite said Michaels was unaware and displayed poor insight for many weeks after the crash. When she began to become more aware, Michaels and her family told Waite that causing harm like the collision was not in her nature.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
Abby Michaels began to cry as Dr. Waite described her last days before release from the hospital. In April of 2019, Michaels was released with the recommendation of follow-up psychiatric care.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
The court has gone into a brief recess.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
4:22 p.m.: Court has resumed session. The prosecution is now questioning Dr. Waite.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
Dr. Waite said she believes there is some confirmation bias related to the initial EMT report. Some hospital professionals reported the crash was likely a suicide attempt. Waite said she disagrees.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
“I don’t believe this was a change from her baseline two weeks before.”
Waite explained that it is possible Michaels was suicidal at the time, however, it does not line up with her personality to attempt suicide in this manner.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
“People don’t just do that.”
The prosecution brought up that other professionals reported Michaels was suicidal the night of the crash. “That doesn’t mean they can read her mind, neither can I,” Dr. Waite responded.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
4:48 p.m.: The court has gone off the record while the lawyers and judge speak with Dr. Waite.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
The prosecution brought evidence showing that after 2016, Michaels had not had a documented seizure between then and the collision in March of 2019.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
Dr. Waite pointed out that this does not mean she did not have one, only that she did not seek medical care.
Prosecution: “Would suicidal ideation in the two months leading up to the collision be important to you?”
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
Dr. Waite: “Yes.”
The prosecution presented Dr. Waite with the messages Michaels sent her husband the night of the crash.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
Dr. Waite mentioned that Michaels feeling like she’s about to die can be a symptom of a panic disorder, and may explain the texts.
“Feeling like I’m dying now doesn’t mean I’m going to drive down I-75 and kill a bunch of people,” Dr. Waite said.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
Prosecution: “Do you think that she was suicidal on March 17, 2019, now that you have seen this?”
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
Dr. Waite: “Yes.”
Still, Dr. Waite maintained that it was a seizure that likely caused Michaels to lose control of her vehicle.
Court has recessed for the day.
— WDTN (@WDTN) June 7, 2023
The defense has no other witnesses and has rested its case. The prosecution will present a rebuttal at 1:30 p.m. Thursday afternoon.